Lovely Idol caused me a mayor deja vu with a cast composed of Shuffle! girls and The manager, Tomohiro, looking like a Yuiichi clone from Shakugan no Shana, but at the very least i can say i wasn’t trying to be any of those things. It could have been better in terms of dialogue, it looks like everyone is reading a script placed by the camera man, with no pauses its severely lacking realism.
Animation on the faces has to be improved, since the girls look like robots when trying to look sad and what not. They could also do a better character introduction since none of the character really stands out i forgot their names as soon as i finished the episode. But I’m not asking for Haruhi Suzumiya to replace a lead girl, this does have some good aspects which makes it Worth watching, but compared to the rest of Fall anime i’ve watched until now i can’t say this one will live long enough in my hard drive.